top of page
cathy pic for expert brochure.png
cathy pic for expert brochure.png

Providing Expert Support for Dog Bite Litigation Challenges

Catherine J. Crawmer
 
Expert Witness
Litigation Support 
​
​
​
​


 

    CASE EVALUATION

.  Deposition Preparation
.  Trial Testimony
.  All Legal Matters

   DOG BITE / ATTACK


.  Behavior Analysis
.  Temperament Evaluations
.  Dog Pack Dynamics
.  Breed Identification


  MUNICIPAL ANIMAL     CONTROL

.  Animal Control Officers
,  Safety Equipment 
.   Safety Protocols
.   Animal Cruelty Cases
.   Procedural Analysis
Dangerous Dog Evaluations
NY State Agriculture &
  Markets Dangerous Dog  Cases



     ON SITE CONSULTANT 
  EVALUATIONS / TRAINING

.  Municipal Shelters
.  Humane Societies
.  Rescue Groups
.  Boarding Facilities
.  Day Cares
.  Trainers
.  Grooming  Establishments
.  Service Dog Providers
.   Breeders

 

Catherine Crawmer is a Dog Behavior Consultant who specializes in providing expert witness and consulting services for all dog related litigation. Her goal is to support legal professionals with in-depth analysis, case evaluation, and educational resources focused on canine behavior, canine welfare, and liability, ensuring they are well-equipped to handle complex scenarios.

​

​

Dog Bite / Attack

Dog bites may involve minor injury but may also result in life altering circumstances.  Secondary events can be significant when there are falls, property damage or work interruptions. 

 

Often overlooked can be the psychological damage due to the experience of having gone through what can be a terrifying event.  

​

Dog attacks, involving one or more animals are serious events.  Fatalities from these attacks have increased in recent years.  The reasons for these attacks are variable but there are some circumstances involving negligence involving irresponsible owners, inadequate enforcemnt of municipal codes and unresponsive animal control departments.  

​

Overcrowding of municipal animal shelters is an issue in most communities with the numbers of dogs and cats available for adoption far exceeding the population seeking to adopt.  Closing the shelter doors, refusing to accept stray, homeless or animals being turned in by their owners has been a solution utilized by privately run animal shelters to maintain a "no kill" facility. While the private shelter has that option the municipal system does not.  A municipal shelter has the responsibility of public safety.  Roaming dogs, whether individuals or running in packs can be highly problematic.   Responsible laws and practices must be implemented within the community to address the animal population within it. 

​

Fatalities and serious dog attacks saw a shocking increase in recent years. 2025 was the 3rd consecutive year in which dog attack fatalities reached 70.  The US record for dog related fatalities reached 71 in 2024.  The public is at risk when dangerous dogs are not properly contained.  Dangerous dogs should not be offered for adoption to the public by rescue groups, animal shelters or municipalities.  Statistics have shown that children are at the most risk.  Municipalities should have a plan to contain dogs that are involved in court ordered holds while cases are being processed.  

 

​​Employees of animal shelters, municipal holding kennels, day cares and boarding kennels need both the education and the equipment to protect themselves.  OSHA regulations detail generalities but specialized information is designed to target the challenges often seen in these facilities.  Catherine Crawmer will assist in litigation support in these areas.  Also available are on sight and in person seminars and presentations for employees and managers.

​

Animal Control

Catherine Crawmer served as an Animal Control Officer for more than 33 years.   As a speaker/lecturer on a host of relevant subjects she has conducted training for the public, municipal leaders, animal control officers and law enforcement personnel hosted by various organizations including, the NY State Department of Agriculture and Markets, the NY State Humane Association and Albany Law School.  Ms. Crawmer has authored two municipal animal control laws. Expert opinion  and case evaluation will be given on related animal control matters, including but not limited to;
 
Dangerous dogs
Animal Control Officers Standard and Practices 
Safety and Equipment Use 
Municipal Kennels
Dog Behavior
 
During her 33 year position as animal control officer Catherine Crawmer was involved in more than 150 Dangerous Dog cases pursuant to the NY State Department of Agriculture and Markets Article 7 Sec. 123
 
At the direction of Courts, Catherine Crawmer has evaluated the temperament and behavior of dogs, making recommendations, to the Court, for training and containment of dogs involved in NYS Department of Agriculture and Markets Dangerous Dog Hearings​​.

Dog Training

​More than 60 years training dogs!  Catherine Crawmer is a full time trainer with extensive experience conducting group classes and private sessions.  Basic, advanced obedience and competition with all breeds, AKC obedience, agility, conformation and specialized & unique behaviors.  Problem correction and aggression toward other animals and people a specialty.  Owner of Crawmer's Animal Training, Catherine Crawmer is training director of all phases of training from basic to show competition.   Catherine spent many years in the AKC sport of dog obedience, acquiring both major wins and multiple obedience tittle with her own dogs as well as those owned by others.   In the 70s she trained Crawmer's Who Done It UD.  This Doberman was the youngest Doberman in the history of the breed to achieve that title.  She also trained and competed with the youngest standard poodle ever to achieve a CD title.  Those records stand today, more than 30 years later.  Many of her students compete in various disciplines and there are many top winners among them.
 
 
Dog training is both an art and a science.  There are many qualified trainers working in the field today who employee various methodology that is both effective and humane.  The public has many options including direct involvement and attending group sessions with others in a hands on modality or sending a dog to a boarding kennel where a trainer will train the dog involving the dog owner later in the program.  Some systems will involve a combination of both.  Each situation is different and a program can be designed to accommodate the dog owner and the dog for the best possible outcome.   Dog training can involve training for house pets, for sports of a wide vareiety as well as training to do specific work such as detecting various scents for law enforcement.  Their work is so diverse that a professional trainer may spend his entire career in only one area of dog training.  This specialization has both advantages and disadvantages.  Methodology and the use of certain types of equipment tends to be more or less acceptable from one trainer to another.  It has often been said that the only thing two trainers can agree upon is that the third one is wrong.  Evaluation of professional performance has to involve a broad base of experience and education. Catherine Crawmer has had an insatiable desire to learn which has expanded over 60 years of involvement with dogs and dog training. 
 
Dog trainers learn their trade in various ways.  Many learn by working with an established professional.  Others start their career in a school designed to train the trainers.  Professionalism and competence should be an expectation of the public.

Catherine Crawmer has been asked to review the proposed curriculum for proprietary  schools to train dog trainers for the NY State Department of Education division of proprietary schools.

Animal Cruelty, Neglect & Hoarding

Unfortunately, animal abuse and neglect makes the news in all parts of the country.  Law enforcement, animal shelters and rescue groups find themselves faced with situations that are difficult to talk about and even harder to deal with.  The species of animal could be just about anything from small pet to farm animal and everything in between.  The abuse or neglect can involve a single animal or be a systematic  situation involving multiple animals, sometimes hundreds.   The invstigation into allegations must be done correctly, the warrants and the seizure of animals must follow certain rulings and the care and veterinary services provided in these cases must be performed in accordance with reasonable care and legal  guidelines.

​

Catherine Crawmer has been involved in all aspects of investigation, seizure and  legal matters on many animal cruelty cases while acting as animal control officer for 4 municipalities.  As the President of the Board of Directors of a large animal shelter, Animal Control Officer and volunteer she was on site, as well as on the planning committee, of three of the largest animal seizures in NY State.  Farm animals, dogs and cat hoarding and neglect cases require specialized operations. 

 

Catherine Crawmer has been involved hands -on in multiple seizure situations in the planning,  transport and after care, Catherine is familiar with the challenges and responsibilities of handling animal cruelty/neglect operations.  

​

Hoarding can involve items, animals, or both.  Mental illness can contribute to a person accumulating animals that they can not care for to the point where their living situation, as well as that of the animals they accumulate, is dangerous and/or unlivable.   Animal control officers are faced with hoarders in their job and Catherine Crawmer has faced this unfortunate reality many many times over her 33 year position as Animal Control Officer.

​

Animal owners have rights too and if animals are properly kept and lawfully licensed  these animal owners  cannot be harassed by individuals or groups who  under the "animal rights" definition seek to  stop owners from owning animals for pets, showing, sports, hunting, breeding or any other legal animal related activity.  

Grooming

Grooming of dogs in this country is a multi-million dollar  business.  Dog owners take this seriously and take their dogs to professional groomers on a regular basis.  Some breeds are groomed once a month and show dogs even more.  Grooming services are available in stand-alone establishments or as part of the services provided in pet shops, kennels and veterinary practises.  Grooming vans are also employed in most areas of the country.  These self-contained units drive to the client's home and bathe and groom pets in the driveway or on the street.

Groomers can learn their skill in a number of ways which include, working with an established professional, doing an online course, attending a State licensed trade school or joining a program to train groomer employees offered by one of the national pet store chains.  Only a few States require dog groomers to license as such.  The skills of a groomer, the competence of performance, the safety measures employed during the service are variable in quality leaving patrons on theri own to select their groomer.

 

Catherine Crawmer has been grooming dogs for more than 60 years, having trained under a student of the NY School of Dog Grooming then working in the profession from then to the present time.  She has owned stand alone grooming shops and provided mobile grooming. 

​

An exhibitor of multiple AKC conformation Champions Catherine Crawmer is a recognized expert of grooming ad conditioning show dogs.  She has given seminars on multiple grooming related subjects in various venues including the Groomerama and the Intergroom, both international grooming conventions and contests operated by Shirlee Kalstone, grooming school owner and author of several books on grooming for the professional.  Catherine Crawmer worked for a number of top professionals in the grooming industry including Calvin Hartman, Joyce Peeples, an Dr. Rebecca Tansil and Joyce Peeples.  

​

​

​

​

Kennels & Day Care

Kennels are businesses where an animal may be housed for any one of a number of reasons.  Owners may be going out of town, have work done on their property, be hosting a large gathering where the family pet will have to be housed elsewhere during that time.  Kennels may be part of a training process where the animal lives at the kennel for a short or extended length of time.   

​

Kennels, when properly run, are physically safe for the animals, the employees and visitors.  Proper care of the animals within is expected and a healthy envrionment is maintained for the good of all concerned.

​

A breeding kennel may specialize in the producing of show dogs, sport dogs or pets.  Reasonable record keeping and veterinary care is a practice followed by those interested in good practices.

​​

Municipal kennels are spaces where dogs are held for a period of time.  These dogs may be strays waiting for their owners to come forward to claim them.  These kennels also hold dog that are involved in some sort of litigation, which could be animal cruelty or a dangerous dog situation.   

Space for dogs seized may also be provided by a not for profit animal shelter.

These kennels may be owned and operated completely by the municipality.  These kennels may also be commercial enterprises that contract space to a municipality for their needs. 

Safety is a primary concern when dogs are seized and held under the direction of a municipality.  These animals are owned by someone who may be searching for them.  They may be housed because the owner has been taken to a hospital, or incarcerated.  There are many legal considerations involved, some covered in animal related law, some in State or Federal Law.   Municipalities have many obligations.  Dog owners also have rights.  Wading through these confusing factors can be challenging.  Catherine Crawmer has more than 30 years doing just that.  She is ready to provide assistance in this area to attorneys Additionally Catherine is available for consultations, on sight inspections of facilities as well as in person presentations on safety equipment, management practices and dangerous dog handling protocols. 

 

Day Cares are locations where people leave their dogs with the goal of keeping them safe for a time, similar to a kennel, or may have the goal of putting their pet into a social situation so he may interact and play with other animals while he is in residence.  While the goal of the day care may be fun for all, there are challenges.   Injuries and fights are not unusual in these facilities, and employees and animals can be injured.  Requiring oversight and safe practices in management is imperitive in the quality day care operation.

       Dog Parks

The concept is that of a group of dogs running loose in a fenced area while enjoying the company of other dogs, similar to a group of school children playing on swings at a playground.  The  idea is nice, the reality, however, may have some issues. 

 

Managed dog parks may involve registering the dog at the town clerk's office and following some rules to maintain access.  In some parks, there are benches to sit on for the people and obstacles for the dogs to climb on.  Dog Control Officers may monitor these parks and enforce safe practices. 

 

In other parks, there are no rules or guidelines.  Injuries can involve persons being bitten while separating dog confrontations or something as simple as a person being run into by a large, fast moving dog.  The liability in dog parks is the same for a dog owner in any other public venue. 

Dog Breeds

1765215801959blob_edited.jpg

​There are an incredible diversity of breeds of dogs in the world.  Humans and canines have had a close relationship for, it appears, for thousands of years.  Serving in every capacity, from hunting companion to house pet, there seems to be a type and size for every taste.  Originally, the function of a dog breed was more important than the physical characteristics.  If he could hunt, nobody cared what he looked like.  As time went on, there was a concerted effort to produce a physical type that appealed to the eye AND could do the job.​  

​

Today there are breeders who adhere to the accepted breed standard for physical characteristics while stressing the temperament and trainability that promotes the work for which the breed was originated.  They are working these dogs, in hunting, in tracking, in police work etc.

​

At the same time came breeders who concentrated on "the look" while not offering equal importance to a dog suited for the job for which the breed was originated. 

​

It is often said that dogs act according to how you treat them.  This is partially true.  However, breeding DOES matter.  Good behavior is trained, this is true, but good temperaments are inheritable. Training and temperament do not have interchangeable meaning.  Temperament is a mix of genetics, breed tendencies and early experiences.  Puppies can exhibit at a very young age, boldness, shyness, adaptability, as well as other characteristics.  Training is learned, not a genetic trait.  The actions of a dog will depend on both training and temperament.

​

Careless, irresponsible and intentionally harmful breeding has produced some lines of dogs not suitable for pets.  This can be confusing when one breed name is used to denote both the best and the worst.  

​

Additionally, some of the characteristics, considered ideal in a working dog, can prove unfit, or even dangerous, in a home where the dog is frustrated by lack of training and direction.  An active, physically agile, young dog given no direction, neglected or handled inappropriately can be a source of problems.

​

There is no getting around it, the pitbull has been involved in way too many news stories. The breed has its fanciers and its detractors.  Both of them have validity to their arguments.  The sheer number of pitbulls seemed to surge in the 90s, with pitbulls being the dominant breed in animal shelters.  Clearly, there were a lot of the wrong people bent on acquiring the breed, an unfortunate number of them to enhance their own sense of the image they chose to present.  Breeding of inappropriate individuals mushroomed into what is undeniably an issue for the dogs themselves and the public. 

 

At the same time, well-meaning people came forward to help the dogs. These individuals and rescue groups saw the pitbull as maligned and abused and sought to help all of them by getting them into homes.  A closer look at the temperament and suitability of the individual might have been more prudent. Some organizations were operated by people who had the experience and the inclination to carefully select those individual dogs with good temperaments that could become excellent pets, weeding them out from dogs that may prove inappropriate or dangerous in the average home.  These two factions are at war even today.  "Save them all", as compassionate as that sounds, has not served either the dogs or the public to advantage.

   Service Animals

Service Dogs assist their handlers in many ways.  All service dogs perform one or more tasks. Training involves consideration of the individual handler's physical and/or psychological need.  Service dogs can free a person to move independently in areas that he would not be able to access independently. 

 

Service animal use has evolved.  At one point some people were declaring any species a service animal. Some were engaging in inappropriate behavior claiming a right to board planes with all manner of creatures.  Snakes, other reptile species,  various rodents,  cats, and birds of all sizes and types were causing disruptions in businesses all over the country.  This situation prompted the federal government to clearly define what a service animal is and to clarify the parameters of use.  At the present time dogs, and in certain instances miniature horses, are the only acceptable service animal species.

 

Federal law allows service animals access to most locations, including businesses and workplaces as well as apartments that otherwise restrict pets.  Some States have additional privileges beyond the Federal law regarding service dogs in training.

 

Service dogs, handled by the person they assist, can not be legally denied services or access to most public venues and accommodations.

​

Business owners are legally required to make reasonable accommodations for the presence of a service animal.  Certain criteria are acceptable to determine if the animal is, in fact, a service animal. Other members of the public have rights as well.  A service animal has to behave in a reasonable manner that is neither disruptive nor dangerous.  Damage within a business, workplace or apartment is no more acceptable by a service animal than it would be by

​an animal without that designation.  

​​

Confusion exists concerning the definition of

Service Animal, Emotional Service Animal and the

Therapy Dog.  They are not the same thing!

​

​Emotional Service Animals (ESA) are addressed in

Federal law regarding housing.  Property owners and

managers need to know the difference between a

Service Animal and an ESA.  A person with an ESA

may be required to present medical documentation

to establish the need for an ESA.  Certain airlines do

accommodate ESAs with certain restrictions but not

all airlines are the same, so investigation is required.

​

Therapy Dogs are dogs that have met requirements

of one of the several organizations offering tests for that designation.  Therapy Dogs may have access only to those locations where they have been invited to go, and have no lawful privilege beyond what is normal for any other dog.

​

Catherine Crawmer is available for in person seminars and presentations for businesses, apartment managers and public venue managers on the subjects of recognizing, accommodating and the legal considerations of Service Animals, ESAs and Therapy Dogs.

​

DSCF1005.JPG

Only An Animal?

UntitledCapture-01-Copy.jpg

Those of us who have pets are aware of the close bond that can be developed between animal and human.  How close and important that relationship can be becomes obvious when we become aware of what happens in disasters when people risk their lives to save their pets.  Emergency responders are commonly faced with those who will remain in disaster zones if told that their pets cannot accompany them to safety.

​

More and more States are recognizing the need for modern legislation that recognizes the importance of the position pets hold in the family structure.  Pets may be property in some sense but may also be considered in custody and visiting arrangements, even financial responsibilities. The pet depends upon the humans but it is clear that the human dependance on a relationship with the pet is often a significant part of their life.  

 

Social interactions with other people is often achieved by the catalyst of dog walking, achieving meetings that otherwise would not happen.  Depressed or lonely individuals who would not be inclined to engage in physical activities are prompted to tend to the duties of responsibly caring for their animals and will engage in regular walking.  Elderly persons may be particularly vulnerable to loss of a pet when other family members may not be as accessible as they once were. 

 

Dogs are increasingly utilized by professionals treating social disorders in both adults and children.  There are very successful programs in which children read books to dogs who are trained to interact with them.  Some of these children have difficulty interacting with other people yet engaged readily with a dog.​ Dogs visiting nursing homes have had a proven benefit to residents who look forward to visiting with the dogs while sharing stories about some of the pets they have shared their lives with.  There are many accounts of persons who rarely communicate with other people being observed readily communicating with a visiting dog. 

​

Dog, as well as other animals, depend on the relationship with their people.  Animals, like most people, are comfortable with a consistent schedule and  predictable activities.  Disruption in established routines, locations and disruptive changes in family structure can cause a high degree of anxiety in dogs since they commonly share the home environment, in its entirely, with the other family members.  

​

Dogs and some other animals may become dependent on their relationship with other animals in the household.  When animals are raised together, the bonded relationship can be quite pronounced.  When bonded individuals are separated, even to go for a walk or vet visit, there can be a noticeably high stress level which can include pacing, whining, barking or frustration related chewing.  The death or permanent removal, particularly of the more dominant individual, can be problematic for another with a less confident, more dependent temperament.   While not all dogs and cats enjoy friendly relationships there are bonds that exist between certain individuals that are significant.  The loss of a pet may cause stress to the humans involved, but the loss can be particularly difficult for other pets who shared a close relationship with a friend who is no longer there.

 

Littermate Syndrome is a well recognized issue when puppies from the same litter remain together into adulthood.  Simply defined, the dominant personality thinks for all the others.  When the leader is not present confusion and stress related behaviors are common.  The issue can be just as pronounced when puppies from unrelated litters are raised together.  Having several dogs at the same time is normally not an issue as long as puppies are acquired one at a time and an effort is made to bond the puppy with humans during his early development.  When dogs are raised by other dogs humans can lose an important part of the relationship they otherwise would have had.  

UntitledCapture-02-Copy.jpg

Other Animals

Caracara bird 2.jpg

Catherine Crawmer started working in a pet shop at the age of 9 years old!  Working every weekend, one or two nights a week and then every day during summer time off from school She put a lot of time into her animal interests.  This particular pet shop may have been the largest and most species diverse in the country.

 

The word pet did not have the same definition then as it does today.  Offered to the public at that time were all manner of reptiles, bird species considered endangered now, rodents of many species, exotic cats and many species of primate, rarely seen outside zoo environments today.  By the time she was legally able to acquire "working papers" she had 7 years of exotic animal handling and training experience.

​

The relationship with animals continued and went in several directions.  She purchased some land from her friend who owned an operating zoo  and Catherine lived for many years only a stone's throw from the largest collection of big cats in NY State.  She had the opportunity to interact with other zoo animals as well, learning from highly experienced personnel.

 

A popular speaker about birds, Catherine has produced videos on training birds, of several species, and presented her work at bird clubs.​

​

As a fancier of poultry Catherine exhibited at shows and presented programs on various species of chicken and waterfowl.

​

Handling unusual and exotic animals that find their way into animal shelters is an issue for those with no training  or experience handling or caring for these species.  Catherine has presented programs to staff, management and volunteers of animal shelters and rescues to facilitate safe and appropriate care of these animals.

​

A vulture species, the Crested Cara Cara was a zoo animal on exhibit when the zoo owner retired . Not a young bird at that time Carrie became Catherine's special project.  The work that was done on training this bird was turned into videos that were used to teach applied behavior analysis. Presented by Catherine Crawmer at the International Association for Behavior Analysis convention, The Marine Mammal Trainers Association, The Zoo Keepers Association and more.  One tape in particular was used by experts teaching applied behavior analysis and shown all over the world by several including Karen Pryor,  Dr. Kent Johnson at Morningside School used the tape as well for training.  Dr. Jon Bailey, Head of the Psychology Department,  utilized Catherine's training tapes to teach his students at Florida State University.

​

One of the educational videos Catherine presented at the International Association for Behavior Analysis convention was viewed by educators from all over the world.  Demonstrating the applied principals of operant conditioning this video included her training with a lion, a tiger, a vulture, a parrot, a horse, a house cat and an aquarium fish.  

coon & chicken 020 (2)_edited.jpg

Handling wildlife requires both education and experience. Deciduous animals may lose their parents and be raised by humans.  Reintroducing these creatures into their natural habitat can be challenging.

     Catherine J. Crawmer
             518-477-8230 
      trainemall@aol.com

        Writing

Catherine Crawmer is a prolific author.  Her book on training cats is based upon the operant conditioning video that she produced for a scientific conference.  Wendy was the first cat trained to negotiate dog agility type equipment.  This cat appeared on TV news shows and the videos on this training was shown all over the world by Karen Pryor.  A different cat, Copper, was trained on full size dog agility equipment.  The videos of Copper were filmed outside in a field.  

Cat Book (2)_edited.jpg

Copper is the cat on the cover of the book.  The jump is 24 inches high.  This photo won an award from the International Cat Writer's Association.  Copper's videos were shown at the Tuft University convention.

​

Catherine Crawmer served as editor of The Trainer's Forum, newsletter for the special interest group of the International Association for Behavior Analysis.

Micky cover (2).jpg

Catherine Crawmer published the American Animal Trainer Magazine.  A publication that went to more than 60 countries around the world.  The goal to introduce animal trainers, from diverse experiences, handling a wide array of species was realized.  The contributions to this magazine included trainers and behavior experts in elephants, big cats, reptiles, marine mammals, horses, dogs, house cats and more.  

​

Over the years Catherine has written many articles on the care and training of various species, both domestic and exotic species, animal control related issues, animal shelters and pit bulls  for a host of print and on line publications including Animals Exotic and Small, Animal Finder's Guide, Trainer's Forum newsletter, K-9 Cop, American Animal Trainer Magazine and more.

518-477-8230

Catherine Crawmer

P.O. Box 364

West Sand Lake,

New York 12196

© 2035 by Dog bite consultant. Powered and secured by Wix 

bottom of page